Jump to Navigation
Book Review

IWO JIMA: World War II Veterans Remember the Greatest Battle of the Pacific.


Click the photo to buy the book.

The battle for Iwo Jima lasted five long weeks and involved three Marine Corps divisions (the lst, 3d and 5th). The amphibious assault began on the morning of Feb. 19, 1945, and by the time the island was declared secure, 36 days later, 28,686 men had died or were wounded in action, making it one of the costliest of the Pacific Island campaigns.

There were 27 Medals of Honor earned during the struggle for possession of the island. Much of the time, success of a mis­sion boiled down to one or two ordinary individuals, committing extraordinary acts of courage.
Many of the stories involved in those heroic battles have never been reported. Today, most of the Marines, who fought there and survived, have passed on. Those still living are in their 80s or 90s. Many who died took their memories of the fight with them to their graves.

However, 22 of those still living agreed to be interviewed by author Larry Smith, and their stories are told in his book “Iwo Jima: World War II Veterans Remember the Greatest Battle of the Pacific.” The result is a long overdue work—one of many that should have been written to capture the first-person recollections of those who survived this and other historic fights. A few of those who were interviewed died before this book was published.

Smith’s book also gives glimpses of the fight as seen by the enemy, through captured documents and diaries, and includes an interview with the daughter of one of the island’s defense commanders, who sur­vived the battle.
Japanese Lieutenant General Tada­mi­chi Kuribayashi, the island’s overall commander, had ordered a departure from the norm in his defense of the island. Instead of trying to defeat the landing Marines on the beaches, he organized his defenses into interlocking fields of fire and myriads of interconnecting tunnels and pillboxes, which did devastating damage to each of the divisions. Also addressed is the mystery surrounding Kuribayashi’s own demise.

The book takes a look at the controver­sy about the two flag raisings on Iwo Jima and includes an interview with Corporal Charles “Chuck” Lindberg, who helped put up the first flag. He died a few weeks after being interviewed by the author.

One chapter tells how Private First Class Samuel Tso saw the war and gives his views on the importance of his role as a Navajo Code Talker. Two Medal of Honor Marines tell their stories in modest prose, underlying the horrors and harrowing events that earned for them, the nation’s highest decoration for valor.

The real value of Smith’s book lies in the fact that the stories we read are told in the voices of those who experienced the fight. Smith does very little editing in what or how it is said. While the memories might be dimmed or distorted by the expanding years between the event and now, most of the survivors tell their tales as if the events had occurred yesterday, instead of nearly 60 years ago.

After reading Smith’s book, I recently was dining at a local restaurant. Seated nearby were two older men and their wives. Both men wore baseball caps that were monogram­med with “WW II Vet” on the bills. As I was leaving, I felt compelled to thank the men for their WW II service. They thanked me for remembering … modest men, who undoubtedly could be the chapters in another author’s book about WW II experiences. I hope their own stories will be told before they, too, pass into history.


 

IWO JIMA: World War II Veterans Remember the Greatest Battle of the Pacific.
By Larry Smith. Published by W. W. Norton & Co. Inc.
320 pages. Stock #0393062341.
$24.21 MCA Members. $26.95 Regular Price.

 

Comments

iwo jima marine

   my father-inlaw, robert wahl, service number  293325, and his daughter Mary, my wife, are trying to find anything about bob.  he was awarded the silver star.  he was a infantry /rifle nco at iwo jima and other islands we are not certain of.  any info that can lead us to bobs' time and units in the service would be much appreciated.  i served in the army on viet nam in 1970.  bob wahl was the finest man i ever knew......

usmc records f/your father-in-law

Your wife, Mary, as the dauther, may request her father's complete usmc personnel records from the National Personnel Records Center in St. Louis Missouri.  Go to www.archives.gov/veterans/military-service records and request standard form 180. In your request, ask for a copy of his UNDLETED records and also request all his medals and Awards.  His records may give you some of what you are looking for.  The records will show what units he was with and from that you can search the enternet for info on when and where his unit served.  Hope this helps.  gunnyjusmcret@yahoo.com. Sempi Fi

possibly last survivor of iwo jima

My father's cousin Ashland Christopher Senopoulos, 91 died and is being buried today in Bourne Ma.

Is he one of the last, if not the last survivor of the battle??   

I was reading an article from a Las vegas newspaper that indicated that a man died in january of 2012  and he was one of two survivors left.  

Peter Senopoulos

There is a member of the

There is a member of the Marine Corps League in Long Island that is a survivor of Iwo Jima. Sorry to hear of your loss

Semper Fi

survivor of Iwo Jima

My Father is a Navajo Code Talker and served in the 4th Marine Division, survived the Battle of Iwo Jima. Is still here with us today.

interview

is there a chance  i could have an interview with him for a National history day reasearch

I have an 86 year old fiesty vet......

In Buffalo NY. Iwo Jima vet. He was gutted by a bayonet and can tell you all about it. The scar and medals will speak volumes. If you are serious, email me (monkd22@aol.com)

Interview Opportunity

Hello,

My name is Daniel Wu an eighth grader in Ellicott Mills Middle School in maryland. I am working on a National History Day research. I wonder if I could have chance to conduct an interview with your father regarding the battle of the Iwo Jima. Thank you very much for your help! my email address is danielchwu@gmail.com

Thanks

Interview Opportunity

Hello!

My name is Daniel Wu an eighth grader in Ellicott Mills Middle School of Maryland. I am working on a National History Day research and I wonder if I could grant an interview opportunity with your father- Mr. Navajo Code Talker about the Battle of Iwo Jima. Thank you very much for your help!My email address is danielchwu@gmail.com

Thanks

Your father

I am very proud of your father who helped save many American live's may God bless your father !

Grave Site at Iwo

Thank You SIR for the Hell you were put thru.

I spent a year on Iwo and WHITE WASHED THE GRAVE MARKERS at the Burial Site while stationed there.

THANKS AGAIN FOR YOUR SERVICE AND CONTRIBUTION TO A FREE AMERICA.

Cleaning grave markers

Thank you for white washing the grave markers at Iwo Gima.

I am really thanking you from all those brave Marines buried there.

I was on many burial details during the Viet Nam War and I can appreciate your task.

God bless you and God bless The United States Marine Corps!

SSGT Michael J. Minardi (ret)

last iwo survivor

I spoke to a man today who was wounded on Iwo Jima with the 5th Marine division.

Not last survivor.

My Dad is nearing death,as I write this, age 89,. he served 4th Marine Div, and survived his tour on IwoJima. he lives in West Dennis,Ma.,very near to your location. there is a Marine also from Iwo Jima,time served, still alive from Salem,Ma. He was a photographer at the time, gentleman is mid-nineties.

Are there any survivors left as of 11/7/2012?

All 9th grade cadets at the Delaware Military Academy read Flags of Our Fathers and would LOVE the opportunity to meet with a Iwo Jima survivor. We would be willing to take a trip to Massachusetts (or wherever) to meet with him. Please advise with ANY information you could provide.

Thank you,

tara.dick@dma.k12.de.us

LAST SURVIVOR OF IWO JIMA?????

HELL NO!!!!!   I  AM STILL HERE..

I WONDER HOW MANY OF US ARE LEFT?????

MIKE

VALLEYFORGE2@HOTMAIL.COM

My grandpa is still alive and kicking at 90 Iwo vet

My. Grandfather Bernard "Jinx" Shaffman is alive and doing well at 90 with two Purple Hearts at 90 years old. He was in the fighting Fourth division on Iwo Jima, Saipan and Tinian. I used to go to all he reunions when I was a kid. He was the president of the reunions at one time. RayShaffman@hotmail.com

My grandpa is still alive and kicking at 90 Iwo vet

My. Grandfather Bernard "Jinx" Shaffman is alive and doing well at 90 with two Purple Hearts at 90 years old. He was in the fighting Fourth division on Iwo Jima, Saipan and Tinian. I used to go to all he reunions when I was a kid. He was the president of the reunions at one time. RayShaffman@hotmail.com

Still here

My grandpa is still here. Las Vegas Nv. Marine corp Iwo Jima

Last survivors

Peter,
On Feb 13th we are headed from Minnesota to DC for the 68th Reunion of The Landing on Iwo Jima. There will be 11 in our group. My father will be with who spent the 36 days on the island. My goal is to have my kids see this with their Grandfather and hopefully pass it down a few generations to their Grandchildren on what they experience with him. The Marine Corps treat this guys like Kings and it sure helps them deal with what they all went through. dterrell@remax.net

Minnesota Iwo Jima Reunion

My dad, Harold Franck, served on Iwo Jima ( Co. Hdq, 24th Marines, 2nd Battalion, 4th Division).  He now lives in Wabasha, MN but lived most of his life in Rochester,MN.  He just turned 88.

We did attend the 50th anniversary in Washington with him.  He would be very interested in connecting with fellow veterans.  My dad also enjoys the high regard of veteran groups and civilians.

We hope you had a wonderful visit, and hope you did not find Washington colder and snowier than Minnesota. Kathy  

thezzzs@comcast.net

 

 

Hey::::  A few of us Iwo Jima

Hey::::  A few of us Iwo Jima survivors are still around and kicking.

my dad is an Iwo Jima survivor

My dad is age 90 and was a Marine who fought on Iwo Jima.

iwo jima

my father is 89 and still living. he was with the 5th marine division, 5th pioneers

A company 2nd platoon. he landed on the 6th wave at 9:30 am on red beach 2.

my email is shotstars11@comcast.net

Iwo Jima survivors

My father survived, and is still living. So is the man who saved his life during the battle. One lives in St. Ignatiis, MO. The other in Laguna Woods, CA. The phone each other at least once a year---on Feb. 19th.

Grandfather survivor of Iwo Jima

My grandfather, 88, is having angioplasty tomorrow, but he is a survivor of Iwo Jima. He also talks of how there were two flags raised and how many others have hassled him over the years for daring to say so.

His name is Paul aka "Go-4", a Navy man who spent three years stationed with the marines, one of the 39 men from Subpack 3 UDT. 

Interview Opportunity

Hello!

My name is Daniel Wu, an eighth grader in Ellicott Mills Middle School in Ellicott City of Maryland. I am working on a National History Day research and I wonder If I could have any chance to conduct an interview with you grandfather about the battle of Iwo Jima. Thank you very much for your help! My email address is danielchwu@gmail.com

Thanks!

 

Father-in-law on Iwo Jima

My father-in-law is 91 and fought on Iwo Jima.  He had pictures of the first flag raising, but lost them in an apartment fire.  He never spoke of the war until his children took him to "Flags of our Fathers".  Greatest respect to all who served.

Marines of Iwo Jima

Where can I find a complete list of the Marines who fought this battle???

Marines on Iwo Jima

There is a book at the Marine Corp Library at Quanitco; Titled The Spearhead, the WW2 history of the 5th Marine Div., Call No D769.37 5TH, C6 1987 3000234993 in which all of the Units and personnel are listed.  It includes casualties with decorations and awards.  Futhermore, it lists Navy personnel attached to each unit. 

Whether or not similar books exists for the 3d & 4th Div.'s is uncertain.  If anyone is aware of a similar book for othe other Div's.......Please post here.

Marines on Iwo Jima

There is a book at the Marine Corp Library at Quanitco; Titled The Spearhead, the WW2 history of the 5th Marine Div., Call No D769.37 5TH, C6 1987 3000234993 in which all of the Units and personnel are listed.  It includes casualties with decorations and awards.  Futhermore, it lists Navy personnel attached to each unit. 

Whether or not similar books exists for the 3d & 4th Div.'s is uncertain.  If anyone is aware of a similar book for othe other Div's.......Please post here.

5th Marines Book

 I have my Dad's book. I'll see if I can find the publisher. If so they probably  published for the other Div.s of the 5th Amp. Corps. I'll post in the next day or 2.

As a former Marine I had the

As a former Marine I had the honor of recently meeting two men who have told me that they served on Iwo Jima.  I would like to see if their names are listed.

Marines of Iwo Jima

Anonymous, this will prove difficult. LtGen Holland M. Smith, Commanding General,Expeditionary Troops, had 60,000 assault troops. Iwo Jima was billed as "the toughest yet" in WW II. These assault units, as reported by noted Marine historian, Colonel Joe Alexander, USMC (Ret), "sustained 24, 053 casualties, by far the highest single-action losses in Marine Corps history." There were 27 Medals of Honor awarded for conspicuous gallantry.
Editor, Leatherneck

Iwo Jima Marine passes away

my dad was a survivior from Iwo Jima, he passed away 11-4-12, his service is 11-15-12, Houston Memorial Cemetary, Houston, Texas with full military honors.

Semper Fi Dad, I will miss you.

Janie Ciancia

Spring, Texas

my uncle died their

My uncle Roy died their ,I wrote a song for him and all those great people that served .You Silent Ones Who Rest In Peace,you can find this song under hanmarbab,channel cookbab thank you

 

6th platoon dog handler attached to 5th div alive and well !!!!!

 My husband Walter Marx Jr was a dog handler in the 6th platoon attacheed to

the 5th marine division on Iwo . I am happy I can say he is alive and well, his

memories of that time are quite clear and vivid. He states at the 1st division

was not on Iwo and that the 3rd only came in later. His dogs story is on the

DPCA web site although that too is not totally correct,but neither is war!

God Bless all who serve and those who wait at home.

My dad

My dad ANGELO FAZZIO  was with the 5th division he made it out and i know the story well  he passed away in march of 09  .  a hero to me . love you dad and thank you for all you did for your country he was friends with ed owens , and dale walker also his sargent was named pace . and ceruso .  

Martin Carroll

I recenly discovered that my Pop-pop, Sgt, Martin C. Carroll, also known as "Red," was a memeber of the 5th division.  Im trying to confirm this or trying to connect with any of his fellow servicemen's family that may recognize the name.  If anyone has any info or suggestions of how to obtain some info please let me know.  Thanks you!

Robert L. Carrmell-3rd Marine Div,.-WWII

 

My husband recently passed 12/16/2012 having served with the 3rd Marine Division and was a survivor of the last Battle on Iwo Jima having seen the raising of the flag.  He met his brother who had been wounded twice there and hadn't seen each other for nearly three years.  My husband died at the age of 87.

Grand Daughter of Iwo Vet

I would like any information or sources anyone can provide on the 4th Marines specifically--My grandfather is Gunny Harold Douglas, served in the 4th Marines and landed on Iwo Jima 19 Feb 1945.  Still alive and kicking today, 91 years of age.  kj51@hotmail.com

Grand Daughter of Iwo Vet

I would like any information or sources anyone can provide on the 4th Marines specifically--My grandfather is Gunny Harold Douglas, served in the 4th Marines and landed on Iwo Jima 19 Feb 1945.  Still alive and kicking today, 91 years of age.  kj51@hotmail.com

Iwo Jima Marine

Robert Lewis Worley

A marine at the young age 18 in 1943 Passed away and today will be laid to rest at Grove Hill Memorial Park , Dallas Texas .

To my hero and grandfather we never forget your service to this country.

You will always be in my heart RIP.

Robert C. Worley

cworley @ suddenlink.net

 

Iwo Jima survivor

I am very sorry for your loss.My dad has passed away but I am still in touch with his friend Jerry Nolte, 90, who served in Iwo Jima and only recently has stopped chopping all his own wood for heat, biking many miles, and fixing everthing in sight. God bless this man; he is now living in Sarasota FL.

Iwo Jima survivor

I am very sorry for your loss.My dad has passed away but I am still in touch with his friend Jerry Nolte, 90, who served in Iwo Jima and only recently has stopped chopping all his own wood for heat, biking many miles, and fixing everthing in sight. God bless this man; he is now living in Sarasota FL.

Iwo jima survivor

My grandfather, Al Antoine Hughes fought in Iwo Jima. He served with the 5th Marine Division, 28th Reg, 1st Platoon. He passed away on 6 January 2013 in his sleep, surrounded by his son and granddaughters, all of whom still looked upon him as the badass that he was. I still won't stop trying to get you the purple heart that you so painfully earned papa; I just wish that you would have been able to see it. I will love you always.

If anyone wants info on "The Spearhead", this is a great, accurate read. My brother gave it to our daddy for Christmas a couple of years ago. My grandfather was one of the marines interviewed by the author!

Allen, Robert E. - THE FIRST BATTALION OF THE 28TH MARINES ON IWO JIMA: A DAY-BY-DAY HISTORY FROM PERSONAL ACCOUNTS AND OFFICIAL REPORTS WITH COMPLETE MUSTER ROLLS

Iwo jima survivor

My grandfather, Al Antoine Hughes fought in Iwo Jima. He served with the 5th Marine Division, 28th Reg, 1st Platoon. He passed away on 6 January 2013 in his sleep, surrounded by his son and granddaughters, all of whom still looked upon him as the badass that he was. I still won't stop trying to get you the purple heart that you so painfully earned papa; I just wish that you would have been able to see it. I will love you always.

If anyone wants info on "The Spearhead", this is a great, accurate read. My brother gave it to our daddy for Christmas a couple of years ago. My grandfather was one of the marines interviewed by the author!

Allen, Robert E. - THE FIRST BATTALION OF THE 28TH MARINES ON IWO JIMA: A DAY-BY-DAY HISTORY FROM PERSONAL ACCOUNTS AND OFFICIAL REPORTS WITH COMPLETE MUSTER ROLLS

Iwo jima survivor

My grandfather, Al Antoine Hughes fought in Iwo Jima. He served with the 5th Marine Division, 28th Reg, 1st Platoon. He passed away on 6 January 2013 in his sleep, surrounded by his son and granddaughters, all of whom still looked upon him as the badass that he was. I still won't stop trying to get you the purple heart that you so painfully earned papa; I just wish that you would have been able to see it. I will love you always.

If anyone wants info on "The Spearhead", this is a great, accurate read. My brother gave it to our daddy for Christmas a couple of years ago. My grandfather was one of the marines interviewed by the author!

Allen, Robert E. - THE FIRST BATTALION OF THE 28TH MARINES ON IWO JIMA: A DAY-BY-DAY HISTORY FROM PERSONAL ACCOUNTS AND OFFICIAL REPORTS WITH COMPLETE MUSTER ROLLS

Iwo Jima Survivor

My father, Clare Gerwien, is the last surviving member of his Navy group who landed on Iwo Jima.  He is 92 and going strong.  He has written about his time on Iwo Jima for all of his children, grandchildren, and greatgrandchildren, and they treasure this booklet.  He has  many interesting stories to tell of his time on the island including many close encounters with death - such as being nearly hit by a Japanese sniper, etc.  My father lives in San Diego, but regularly drives over to visit me in Phoenix.  He would love to talk to any school age children who are interested in the subject of Iwo Jima.

My Grandfather ~ My Hero

John Cahill is an Iwo Jima Veteran from the the 5th. He is alive and well in Hopkinton, MA.

 

Post new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.